After Record Year, University-Endowment Returns Drop Into Negative Territory
Numerous endowments have adopted divestment policies in recent years amid efforts to combat climate change, limiting their exposure.
After Record Year, University-Endowment Returns Drop Into Negative Territory
Endowments post their worst losses since 2009 as stocks, bonds, other assets decline
The endowment of Washington University in St. Louis lost 10.6% in the most recent fiscal year.
PHOTO: ROBERT COHEN/ASSOCIATED PRESS
By Juliet Chungand Melissa Korn
Updated Oct. 31, 2022 4:32 pm ET
Investment returns for university endowments have fallen back to earth after scoring their biggest gains in a generation the year before, reflecting a dramatically changed investment environment in which stocks, bonds and other assets have sold off sharply.
The endowment of Washington University in St. Louis lost 10.6% in the fiscal year ended June 30 after notching a 65% gain the prior year, the school told The Wall Street Journal, shrinking its size to $13.3 billion. Other schools that have reported big swings in their multibillion-dollar endowments include Stanford University, which lost 4.2% after gaining 40.1% previously; Brown University, down 4.6% after posting a 51.5% increase; and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, down 5.3% after rising 55.5%.
What effect might a reduced endowment have on your school or alma mater? Join the conversation below.
The median result for endowments and foundations in the fiscal year ended June 30 was a 7.8% loss, according to a preliminary estimate by Cambridge Associates—the worst showing since 2009. Some endowment chiefs and advisers said the returns likely would have been even worse if venture-capital and private-equity valuations fully reflected the deep declines in public markets, a potential overhang on future performance.
Surging venture-capital returns boosted large endowments’ returns the prior year, ushering in a raft of expanded financial-aid initiatives and other programs despite the fact that some of the gains were unrealized.
Endowments also help fund faculty salaries and capital projects. “If this continues for another year there will be impacts,” said Margaret Chen, global head of Cambridge’s endowments and foundations practice.
Still, she said endowments were cushioned from steeper losses by diversification in their portfolios, which beyond public and private equity and fixed income often include hedge funds, real estate, private credit and cash. A benchmark portfolio made up of 70% global stocks and 30% Bloomberg Aggregate bond index lost 13.8% for the period, according to Cambridge.
Many schools’ use of a “smoothing formula” to determine the size of their endowment’s distribution to their budget has limited fallout from the losses, said Greg Dowling, investment chief of Cincinnati, Ohio-based investment consultant Fund Evaluation Group. Such formulas typically take into account several factors, including an endowment’s average market value over three years or more, in an effort to dampen the effect of wild performance swings.
Public- and private-equities markets have retreated as central banks around the world raise interest rates in the face of surging inflation. The S&P 500, the Nasdaq Composite and the MSCI ACWI index lost 10.6%, 23.4% and 15.4% respectively, including dividends, for the year ended June 30, their biggest losses in more than a decade, according to Dow Jones Market Data.
Oil and gas, a rare bright spot in markets that soared after Russia invaded Ukraine, did little to aid endowment returns. Numerous endowments have adopted divestment policies in recent years amid efforts to combat climate change, limiting their exposure.
One exception was Princeton University, whose endowment benefited from its exposure to fossil-fuel companies, said people familiar with the matter. Princeton in September said it would divest from public fossil-fuel and from thermal-coal and tar-sands companies. The university didn’t address its other private oil- and gas-related holdings. The endowment lost 1.5% in the fiscal year ended in June after a 46.9% gain the prior year, and stood at $35.8 billion as of June 30.
Princeton University’s endowment benefited from its exposure to fossil-fuel companies.
PHOTO: BRYAN ANSELM FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Endowments’ investments in venture capital have proved particularly thorny.
Private companies have postponed initial public offerings and laid off employees. Some, including Instacart Inc. and Klarna Bank AB, have slashed their valuations.
But valuations overall have remained relatively high as managers wait for events like new funding rounds or public offerings to revalue their private investments.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/after-record-year-university-endowment-returns-drop-into-negative-territory-11667188753