These companies are trying to bring more trust to carbon credits The market’s reputation has suffered. But these companies think technology could be one answer.
Greenwishing and Greenwashing are still a pox on carbon markets, without strict accounting that measures and verifies emission reductions.
These companies are trying to bring more trust to carbon credits
The market’s reputation has suffered. But these companies think technology could be one answer.
February 9, 2024
· 5 min read
With buyers ranging from Taylor Swift to Apple, carbon offset credits seem poised to grow in the coming decades as companies work to meet compliance requirements and climate goals.
But it’s been an especially rough few years for the often controversial financial device, in which companies—or individuals—can buy credits for projects that claim to have reduced emissions or removed carbon from the atmosphere to offset (hence the name) their own carbon-producing activities. Multiple reports have questioned the veracity of claims made by projects sold on the voluntary carbon market, casting a pall over the whole system.
That’s where businesses like Sylvera, BeZero Carbon, and Calyx Global want to help. The companies are part of a nascent cottage industry designed to act as ratings agencies for these instruments in the same way companies like Moody’s do for bonds. They generally work on behalf of companies that purchase carbon offsets, doing research to gauge the integrity and efficacy of a given carbon-reduction program, and issuing ratings on their own scales.
Calyx co-founder Duncan van Bergen said there’s been “what you could call a crisis of confidence” in the past couple years, “not because quality credits aren’t out there, it’s just that there is variability.” On the one hand, that’s led to buyers—and risk departments—being savvier about diligence and enlisting the services of companies like Calyx. On the other, if companies have too little trust in the market, they could choose to forgo credits altogether.
“Awareness has grown. And that’s led to more interest in what we do and corporate [clients] reaching out. So that’s been a positive,” van Bergen said. “But obviously, what’s important also in the mid- to long-term, if we’re to have a big and growing business, and that impact realized, is that there is a market. And that the crisis of confidence doesn’t lead to people saying, ‘Well, hey, this is just too touchy, too risky. I’m out.’”
More Stories
Another company bets big on carbon-capture tech
EV leasing ticked down, but hybrids continued to have a moment in January
Coworking: Chris Ellis hears you
Green gauging?
Carbon offset credits have often been at the center of accusations of “greenwashing”—marketing that exaggerates the eco-friendliness of a product—because they allow companies to effectively outsource decarbonization initiatives while continuing to emit carbon themselves. But in ideal practice, they can help fund decarbonization efforts like reforestation and solar installation from companies that might be polluting either way.
That all depends on those projects doing what they say they do. Calyx “looks at the core claim a carbon credit makes…that it stands for one tonne of removed or reduced emissions. Our assessment, our rating, are a gauge to what extent a buyer can rely on that,” he said. To help determine that, Calyx examines factors like whether the climate action would have happened without the project, whether a project is issuing too many credits, and whether it’s creating emissions somewhere else in the process, van Bergen said.
Keep up with the innovative tech transforming business
Tech Brew keeps business leaders up-to-date on the latest innovations, automation advances, policy shifts, and more, so they can make informed decisions about tech.